Why You Leave Every Lawyer Meeting Either Anxious or Overconfident — And Why You Should Consider Self-Representation

(Anonymised. For educational purposes only.)

There’s a cold, uncomfortable truth no one tells people walking into the family-violence and family-law system:

You will leave almost every meeting with your lawyer either:

(1) more anxious than when you arrived, or

(2) unrealistically confident of victory.

There is rarely anything in between.

The reason isn’t personal.

It isn’t because your lawyer is malicious or incompetent.

It’s because this is how profitable legal practice works — and unless you understand it, you’ll get played by a system that feeds on your emotional swings.

This article explains why, and what you must do to stay in control.

1. Anxiety = More Billing

Most clients walk into a lawyer’s office because they feel unsafe, overwhelmed, or confused.

A good lawyer knows this.

A profitable lawyer knows how to use it.

A little fear is a powerful business tool:

• “If you get this wrong, the consequences could be serious…”

• “We need to prepare everything just in case.”

• “The other party is using this as a strategy.”

• “You don’t want to be unprepared.”

• “This is very complex.”

None of these are lies.

They’re statements calibrated to generate dependency.

Dependency leads to

→ more questions

→ more uncertainty

→ more emails

→ more “quick calls”

→ more caution

→ and significantly more billable hours.

I’ve never seen a family lawyer say,

“Relax, it’s simple, you can do most of this yourself.”

You will never hear that sentence from someone charging $450/hour.

––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––

2. Overconfidence = More Billing

When lawyers aren’t selling fear, they’re selling hope.

The tone shifts dramatically:

• “Your case is strong.”

• “The Magistrate was clearly with you.”

• “Their evidence is weak.”

• “We can definitely run this.”

• “I think you’ll win.”

Again, not necessarily false.

But highly selective.

Why?

Because overconfidence leads to

→ more preparation

→ more affidavits

→ more subpoenas

→ more evidence review

→ more strategy meetings

→ more ‘gotcha’ ideas

→ and, once again, more billing.

You walk out thinking you’re about to crush the other side.

You authorise more work.

You approve more hours.

You spend more money.

Then at the next meeting, they tell you something anxiety-inducing again.

This emotional whiplash is not an accident.

It’s the rhythm of the industry.

––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––

3. Lawyers Don’t Do This Because They’re Bad People

They’re not cartoon villains.

They’re operating inside a billable-hour incentive structure that rewards:

• complexity over clarity

• escalation over resolution

• conflict over cooperation

• fear over certainty

• action over efficiency

A lawyer paid by the hour does not make more money by simplifying your case or empowering you to do 80% of it yourself.

They make more money when you are dependent.

Until you understand that, you will be emotionally (and financially) vulnerable.

––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––

4. This Is Why Self-Represented Litigants Often Do Better Than Expected

Yes, really.

Here’s why self-reps often outperform represented parties:

• They know their own facts better than anyone on earth.

No lawyer will ever know your relationship like you do.

• They don’t get manipulated by emotional billing cycles.

No anxiety-addiction loop.

No overconfidence rollercoaster.

• They speak plainly, not in legalese.

Magistrates often appreciate clarity and sincerity.

• They stay focused on outcomes, not process.

Lawyers get paid for the process.

Self-reps focus on results.

• They don’t burn tens of thousands on procedural skirmishes.

They pick their battles because the cost is their own time, not their bank balance.

• The court quietly respects litigants who come prepared.

Not chaotic self-reps — but the ones who:

• file on time,

• cite the law accurately,

• present logically,

• stay calm, and

• don’t play games.

Magistrates have seen enough nonsense to spot authenticity immediately.

––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––

5. If You Must Use a Lawyer, Treat This Rule as Gospel

Here it is — the golden rule every client should write on the inside of their eyelids:

Never outsource your judgment.

Lawyers are advisors, not decision-makers.

You are the CEO of your case.

They are consultants.

That’s it.

That’s the entire secret.

If you walk into a lawyer’s office expecting guidance, you’ll be eaten alive by the emotional billing loop.

If you walk in expecting input, not direction, the dynamic changes instantly.

Here’s how you maintain control:

✓ 1. Never treat your lawyer’s fear as your fear.

Analyse — don’t absorb.

✓ 2. Never treat your lawyer’s optimism as a guarantee.

Ambition is not evidence.

✓ 3. Never approve work you don’t genuinely need.

If they can’t explain the benefit, don’t authorise it.

✓ 4. Always bring your own written goals and strategy.

If you don’t set the agenda, they will.

✓ 5. Question everything.

A lawyer who bristles at questions is a liability.

✓ 6. Know the law yourself.

Even if you hire a lawyer, you still need to know the procedural rules and legislation — or you’ll be led blindfolded off a cliff.

✓ 7. Remember: the person who knows the facts best usually wins.

That’s you — not your solicitor.

––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––

6. Lawyers Hate Clients Who Are Informed — Which Is Why You Must Be One

The legal industry thrives when clients are:

• scared

• confused

• reactive

• overwhelmed

• dependent

• and willing to throw money at the problem

The system becomes far less profitable when clients:

• know the law,

• know the process,

• think critically,

• ask good questions,

• refuse emotional manipulation,

• and insist on evidence, not vibes.

You don’t need to be a lawyer.

You just need to stop behaving like a passenger in your own case.

––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––

7. The Bottom Line

Whether you self-rep or use a lawyer, you must understand the emotional economy of the legal profession.

Lawyers make money when you oscillate between fear and overconfidence.

The antidote is calm, informed, rational self-governance.

Self-representation is often the best path — not because lawyers are evil, but because you are the one with the most skin in the game and the clearest motivation to be honest, efficient, and focused.

If you must use a lawyer:

Use them like a consultant.

Never like a therapist.

Never like a saviour.

And never as the driver of your decision-making.

You win cases with clarity, preparation, evidence, and composure — not with anxiety, bravado, or blind faith in the billable hour.

––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––